USB-C is one of the worst things that ever happened to computers.

Wifewolf
Follow

@tom the power source/sink negotiation is a clever idea right up until it encounters reality

although I'd think with a phone and a computer it shouldn't be *that* hard for them to know to negotiate it the expected way around, so it's still ridiculous that this can occur

@jess @tom I mean it's not that hard to pop up a thing saying "hey you wanna charge this thing or not?", my Android phone does it

@noiob @tom oh yeah, prompting would more or less solve the issue universally but

gotta have that "zero friction" ux, right?

@noiob @jess sorry but there is no way in hell i would EVER want my camera to charge ANYTHING. It's ridiculous that it's even a thing that can physically happen.

@tom @jess well yeah in this case it's absolutely ridiculous, but in the case of the Switch you could argue that charging a controller from the Switch is a valid use case

@tom @someonetellmetosleep @noiob @jess this might also have something to do with the fact the switch is notorious for having non-compliant USB-C ports and might just be ignoring the PD messages and deciding to pull power from the camera anyway?

@tom @Lyude @someonetellmetosleep @noiob @jess pfpt I thought I saw the word switch here but I must have misread something

@jess @tom hell, a very naïve approach that would be better than THIS shit would be…

camera: hi, I see you have USB PD! how much energy do you have? laptop: I have 50,000 mWh camera: I have 2,500 mWh, charge me plzkthx? laptop: k

the worst case is:

laptop: I have 1,000 mWh camera: I have 2,500 mWh, want a charge? laptop: yesplz

then the camera would charge the laptop, but only if the camera has more energy than the laptop

Sign in to participate in the conversation
queer.af

queer.af, your cosy queer space queer.af is a mastodon instance for those who are queer or queer-adjacent who would like a more pleasant social media experience.